McEvoy is no stranger to Bishop Foley, having previously steered the team to a State Finals appearance in 2018. His return marks a significant moment for the school's athletic department, reflecting their continued commitment to excellence in sports and character building among players. As the incoming Head Coach for Bishop Foley's Varsity Baseball, McEvoy aims to instill a sense of pride, passion, and intensity into team values. He cited his enthusiasm about his return:

"I am very excited to be back at BFC. We are going to work hard every day to represent the school with pride, passion, and intensity. Our brand of baseball will be focused on team first, and character based."

With an impressive track record that includes substantial roles in player development and coaching, McEvoy is poised to enrich the Bishop Foley baseball program. He is recognized for encouraging high-character players who are passionate not only about baseball but also about being productive members of the community. His deep familiarity with the Catholic League, special skills, and motivational leadership style are expected to bring about transformative changes in the team and foster a competitive and respectful sports environment.